The Difference Between Eating Paleo and “Being Paleo”

23 Mar

As the Paleo FX Ancestral Momentum – Theory to Practice Symposium (so glad they didn’t go with the long version of the event’s name) wound down last week, it felt like the Paleo blogging world and its faithful audience (hereafter “Paleosphere”) had worked itself up into a frenzy. Over what, I’m not quite sure. It may have just been the gathering of like-minded individuals with strong online presences. What left a lasting impression was the tone of the Paleosphere during the event, and it just so happened that the timely coalescence of Paleo personalities and its ensuing social media onslaught brought everything to a head for me.

You see, I’ve been following a Paleo way of eating for about 18 months now, and it’s had a profound impact on the way I view the world, how I feel, and (obviously) how I eat. I replaced most grains, dairy, legumes, refined sugars, and seed-derived oils with whole foods and many of my autoimmune symptoms went into remission. I can honestly say with conviction that I “eat Paleo”. However, I do not identify myself as “being Paleo”. I think there’s a distinction that needs to be made before we move on.

To me, “being Paleo” means that you are self-identifying with a group. It’s like calling yourself a musician or a video gamer (as opposed to simply writing music or playing video games). The problem with identification is that disidentification – the mentality of “us vs. them”, and a focus on what you are NOT – often emerges. Consider the in-group-out-group bias. This phenomenon can lead to aggression and prejudice, and some suggest that it leads to a lack of productivity, as identifiers take action while disidentifiers tend to just make a lot of talk. (And who is the “them” in this case? Just about everyone else – those pesky grain-eaters that make up the rest of the population, and those cursed Vegans that try and muck everything up!).

While the Paleosphere (thankfully) doesn’t focus too much on the “them” aspect of the diet, there’s definitely an overbearing “us” momentum that isn’t entirely healthy, either. I often see the Paleosphere as being on this slippery slope towards extremism.

As an ever-increasingly-large group of people that eat a similar diet and in many cases hold similar values, I think it’s important we don’t lose sight of the fact that extremists and ideologists often alienate themselves from the rest of society. How are we supposed to make an impact on the nutrition world if we work the Paleosphere up into a frenzied cult status? John George and Laird Wilcox, scholars of fringe movements, have identified the following characteristics of political extremists and ideological contrarians:

1. Absolute certainty they have the truth.
2. [The belief that] America is controlled to a greater or lesser extent by a conspiratorial group. In fact, they believe this evil group is very powerful and controls most nations.
3. Open hatred of opponents. Because these opponents (actually “enemies” in the extremists’ eyes) are seen as a part of or sympathizers with “The Conspiracy,” they deserve hatred and contempt.
4. Little faith in the democratic process. Mainly because most believe “The Conspiracy” has great influence in the U.S. government, and therefore extremists usually spurn compromise.
5. Willingness to deny basic civil liberties to certain fellow citizens, because enemies deserve no liberties.
6. Consistent indulgence in irresponsible accusations and character assassination.

Does that sound alarmingly familiar to you? Admittedly, the above characteristics have a major political slant, and the fact that big corporations have major influence on what ends up on our dinner plates may not lead to some of those characteristics (like the willingness to deny basic civil liberties part).

I can’t deny that a relatively extreme diet (side note: it’s sad that the Paleo diet is considered “extreme” in this age of processed/fast foods) will attract people that gravitate towards fringe thinking – as sociologist Daniel Bell put it, for those on the fringe, “the way you hold beliefs is more important than what you hold. If somebody’s been a rigid Communist, he becomes a rigid anti-Communist – the rigidity being constant.” How many ex-Vegans are in the Paleosphere? Lots. (As some would argue: not enough.) An extreme lifestyle will attract extremists, which simply isn’t preventable. My point is this: just because there are crazies in the Paleosphere, we don’t have to listen to them, and we need to keep ourselves in check to make sure we don’t become them. An easy way to prevent this is to continually challenge ourselves to question our dietary standards, and to avoid dogmatism.

So where do we start? How can we make sure that we promote this diet in the most open, pragmatic, unobtrusive, and inclusive way? Here are some quick suggestions:

1. Don’t tell people that you “are Paleo”. Hell, don’t even tell them that you eat “Paleo”, because the use of labels is in itself exclusionary. Just tell them what you eat, and maybe what you don’t eat. It doesn’t need to be more complicated than that. Look at the Weston A. Price dietary guidelines. It’s very similar to the modern interpretation of the Paleo diet, and they don’t tell you what to avoid, even once. Focus on the whole foods, not on yet-to-be-completely-proven-as-evil grains, legumes, etc.

2. Don’t use flawed ideas or gray areas to promote the diet, because it calls the Paleosphere’s credibility into question. Don’t worship bacon, which is likely not good for you, even if it is (was) somewhat fashionable to “baconize” stuff. It’s a useful ingredient in cooking, but it’s not our flagship food. Don’t celebrate “Paleo versions” of sweets like Paleo brownies because that’s not helping people overcome their underlying food issues and if anything it’s guiding them towards failure. The last thing we should do is to set people on shaky foundations. Personally, I’m all about Dr. Kurt Harris‘ incremental process, because it encourages folks to improve their health even when they’re not ready to dive into a full-blown Paleo eating orgy.

3. Avoid dogmatic thinking. Are potatoes evil? What about white rice? What about dairy? Aren’t we supposed to be eating low carb? Remember that human variance, health history, and gut flora are major factors in food tolerance, and macronutrient ratios are highly individualized. This diet is ever-changing (and it should be as scientific study helps enlighten our views on nutrition every day); be open to suggestion.

4. Try not to alienate others by flaunting an overbearing self-identification of “being Paleo.” You’re not a caveman, and you’re certainly not living like one, so why label yourself as one? If anything, I suggest embracing what we do have in common with our ancestors – the fact that we’re all on this planet. Go take a walk/hike. Watch a sunset. Spend a few days camping. That’s certainly closer to being a caveman than eating a pound of lean red meat straight out of a slow cooker after a hard day at the office and then blogging about it.

5. Bear in mind that everyone has their own burden. I’m pretty sure that most people simply cannot afford to eat fresh organic vegetables and grass-fed meats all the time. My family can’t afford it, despite the fact that a huge chunk of our income goes towards our groceries – nearly twice as much as before we switched our diet. Additionally, many people don’t have the resources to find out whether or not they have access to affordable grass-fed meats anyway – online resources are often outdated, and I’ll wager that many excellent farmers are out working and not updating their farm’s webpage and social networking fan pages. Many don’t have access to local, affordable health food markets. This is no reason to make people feel bad for having to make sacrifices to make ends meat meet; instead celebrate the steps that people are willing to take for their health that are within their means.

6. Avoid the fringe, and consider the power of prudence. What is the point of wearing t-shirts that say “Meat is awesome” or “Vegans suck”? Before shouting from the rooftops about how stuff like cold thermogenesis and eating butter straight out of the container is awesome, take a step back and think about how crazy that sounds to the average person. I’m not saying that any of those extreme elements are bad, but they might not be helping the Paleo movement along when that’s the stuff we get identified with. When it comes down to it, who better to police the Paleosphere than ourselves?

Lastly, please don’t take this as an insult to anyone that’s exhibited these behaviors. Dramatically improving your health through simple changes in diet is awesome, and exciting. I don’t fault you for telling people that “you’re Paleo”. My only purpose in writing this article is to help consider the fact that we need to do what we can to impact those that aren’t lucky enough to know much about sensible eating yet. As much as it may be fun to be part of a cool, elite club of Paleo dieters that share cool pictures and sayings amongst themselves, isn’t our energy better spent on refining the diet itself through scientific study and attracting people that haven’t been exposed to the diet yet?

25 Responses to “The Difference Between Eating Paleo and “Being Paleo””

  1. mem March 23, 2012 at 5:27 pm #

    Thank you, Russ. Excellent content that all of us need to take some time to ponder, and excellently written as well. 🙂

  2. zenkamal March 23, 2012 at 5:28 pm #

    Best paleo social commentary of the year. Oops, didn’t mean to use “paleo”.

  3. PaleoPeriodical March 23, 2012 at 5:46 pm #

    Bravo! I say that even though I identified with many of the traits in that list of fringe identifiers. Maybe I need an intervention. But as human animals, it makes sense that we have to, to some degree, be convinced of the rightness of our decisions otherwise, why would we decide that way? Also, how do we work for change without acknowledging the “wrongness” of Big Pharma, industrialized agriculture, etc.?

    These are things I’ve wrestled with myself. One of my peeves is when Paleofolk talk smack about fat people. It wasn’t that long ago that I didn’t understand the four million factors working against me being a healthy human being, and I haven’t forgotten what it’s like to not know where to look for answers. I mean, I get it. I see evidence of it too. Everywhere. But I try not to let that turn into exasperation or judgment. It’s actually more likely to make me cry.

    Anyway, thanks for the thoughtful post.

    • Russ Crandall March 23, 2012 at 6:33 pm #

      Thanks Karen. Honestly, this post was borne out of identifying my own behaviors as I’m making my way through this journey. I agree that we can and will feel strongly about the rightness of our decisions (especially in the Paleo world, with all that red meat / testosterone flying around!), it’s the use of the word “absolute” that scares me.

      Also, I guess my point behind disidentification isn’t that we need to lay off the agricultural wrongs that are contributing to our poor health, but rather the cliquishness of the Paleo movement and how that exclusivity can possibly leave people with a bad taste in their mouths.

      By all means we do need to have it out with Big Pharma! 🙂

      • rnikoley March 28, 2012 at 2:43 pm #


        This is a needed wake up call on many levels. I’d like to discuss further with you. Looked for contact info here & one your own blog, but if you could email me rn@ [my blog domain] .com I’ll tell you what I have in mind.

  4. Meredith March 23, 2012 at 6:29 pm #

    Russ, this is a great post. Very thoughtful. It’s hard to strike the balance of having a community while not spiraling into tribalism. A delicate balance indeed!

  5. Martha Perry March 23, 2012 at 6:49 pm #

    This was so very terrific. Thank you for all you do and all you say to help us walk this world gentle of voice and acts.

  6. Travis March 23, 2012 at 7:28 pm #

    This needed to be said and you did it well. Bravo!

  7. sharibaby13 March 23, 2012 at 7:57 pm #

    Excellent post Russ! Very timely. I think we, as a community, need to take a step back from the furor and take an objective look at how we behave and how we present ourselves to others outside the community. In my opinion we’re looking more than a little crazy these days. I hope people will really think about this and that it fosters at least a desire for some real change.

  8. livecleancookdirty March 24, 2012 at 7:07 pm #

    I definitely appreciate this post and feel it is timely. The times I see myself leaning toward being “a paleo” is when I feel like I am looking for a sense of community. It is too easy to feel like the freak and, frankly, not too many other people want to hear about MovNat or the best methods for making bone broth. So I think the tendency is to try to band together. That being said, I lean toward an all-inclusive attitude and try not to alienate anyone. I agree that the best way to help people is by expanding the science and being open to all.

  9. alisongolden March 28, 2012 at 9:45 pm #

    I loved this post and it is something I’ve noticed from many a conference I’ve been to and observed in these social media times. Living in the wilderness and having relationships with people over social media seems to set up a frenzy when people finally get to meet in real life. That’s not to say it’s bad or unreal, it’s simply an observation of how movements that start on the fringe can evolve these days.

    I agree with everything you say here especially this: “Personally, I’m all about Dr. Kurt Harris‘ incremental process, because it encourages folks to improve their health even when they’re not ready to dive into a full-blown Paleo eating orgy.”

    I work to help people break down the paleo lifestyle into tiny nibbles they can chew on and digest easily. We need to continue scientific research and push the message but a bottom up approach helping to make changes in people’s lives on an individual basis in tiny increments is essential to get people moving away from SAD while we wait for policy to change (!)

  10. selloholicmom March 29, 2012 at 2:03 pm #

    Great read!

  11. Dave Wendel (@dwendel) March 29, 2012 at 2:33 pm #

    Excellent article and several good points to think about. I had a yoga teacher that used to eat meat then (this was two years back) she went to Jivamukti training which in short really promotes being a Vegan. The Jivamukti yoga was great but then came the preaching about how eating meat is bad and animal cruelty. I still like this teacher but stopped going to the her yoga classes because I got sick of hearing about why I should be a vegan.
    The same goes for the Paleo movement, I think if people ask for advise give it to them but trying to convince them why they are wrong doesn’t jive.

  12. Russ Crandall ( March 29, 2012 at 2:46 pm #

    Quick note: the two references to fringe thinking – the quote about political extremists and the pro/anti communist line – both come from this book, “Denying History” by Michael Shermer and Alex Grobman:

  13. laura h March 29, 2012 at 3:28 pm #

    Thanks for this post! Some people out there are thinking, you give me hope. 🙂

  14. Katie @KatieDid March 29, 2012 at 3:46 pm #

    love it! trying to move away from labels as much as possible lately. “I eat real, whole foods from the earth, most of the time” is what I’m trying to live by lately. No not always. And I definetely don’t know everything but doing the best I can with the knowledge that I do have. Thanks for sharing this, I have lots to ponder on while I’m working tonight 🙂

  15. CheyenneCharlie March 30, 2012 at 12:51 am #

    Reblogged this on Buying Cooking Serving the Best Foods and commented:
    A good article about the paleo template food plan

  16. Darknessrebornhack.Com December 29, 2014 at 9:44 am #

    He designed the dome of Saint Peter’s Basilica and painted the Sistine Chapel frescoes.
    alsoenjoy a color: #b86000; text-decoration: none;.
    Another popular touring band named, ‘Misfortune 500’ boasts two
    art school alums, Natalie Gazaway and Chisolm Thompson.

  17. mesin kasir March 30, 2015 at 11:53 pm #

    Wonderful post! We will be linking to this great content on our site.
    Keep up the good writing.


  1. Guest Post: The Difference Between Eating Paleo and “Being Paleo” | Free The Animal - March 29, 2012

    […] above was recently posted on the Highbrow Paleo blog. Russ Crandell also blogs at The Domestic Man where he posts many wonderful recipes with lots of […]

  2. Reblog: The difference between eating paleo and being paleo | Primal Bodybuilding and Health - March 30, 2012

    […] article was recently featured on the Highbrow Paleo blog. Russ Crandall also blogs at The Domestic Man where he posts many wonderful recipes with lots of […]

  3. Not all “paleo” diets are the same. Also, the label kind of sucks. - March 31, 2012

    […] there’s a difference between eating paleo and being paleo. Russ Crandall at Highbrow Paleo makes a case that people shouldn’t say they are paleo because it makes them self-identify with a group, […]

  4. What’s crazier: eating plants and animals (aka “paleo”) or eating beaver anal gland secretions? | Pain Database - April 18, 2012

    […] a carrot is technically processing it, as is cooking. I certainly wasn’t going to say “I’m paleo“, at risk of sounding like a douchebag. Conclusion: I just won’t say anything at all, […]

  5. Paleo Diet Granola Recipe - March 18, 2013

    […] introduced in the book was that our bodies were ‘built’ a certain way to process the food we eat because of our prehistoric ancestors. Not only did this intrigue me it made so much […]

  6. Guest Post: The Difference Between Eating Paleo and "Being Paleo" | Free The Animal - February 1, 2014

    […] article was recently featured on the Highbrow Paleo blog. Russ Crandall also blogs at The Domestic Man where he posts many wonderful recipes with lots of […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: